ZS Crossover II L.P. Delivers Letter to Capital Southwest Corporation's Board of Directors
Demands One Time $82 Per Share Distribution to Shareholders, Plans to Withhold Votes for Company's Slate of Directors Unless Tangible Action is Taken NEW YORK, May 29 /PRNewswire/ -- ZS Crossover II L.P. ("Crossover") announced today that it sent a letter dated May 29, 2008 to the Board of Directors of Capital Southwest Corporation ("CSWC") (NASDAQ:CSWC) urging the Board to take decisive action to protect against further erosion of shareholder value, including making a one time $82 per share distribution of cash and securities to the Company's shareholders.
In the letter Crossover expressed its belief that CSWC is currently not properly valued by the market due to CSWC's poor investment performance history and cavalier valuation procedures. Crossover demanded that CSWC take steps to sell its approximately $54 million of unrestricted public securities and to register and distribute its holdings in ALG, HLYS, PHHM and WIRE. Ned Sherwood, speaking on behalf of Crossover, stated, "We estimate that such a sale and distribution would result in shareholders receiving approximately $82 per share in cash and securities at current market prices, though the exact amount may vary. After this distribution, CSWC would still have approximately $8 per share in cash, more than $85 per share of value in its privately held securities portfolio and no debt. We believe that following this distribution, CSWC's stock price would trade much closer to this remaining net asset value of approximately $93 per share. Thus, by our calculations, shareholders could own a stock likely valued at close to $93 per share while also having $82 per share in cash and securities in their direct control, equal to approximately $175 per share, a nearly 50% premium to CSWC's recent stock price of $119."
Mr. Sherwood continued, "We are displeased with the current Board's cavalier attitude towards the valuation of CSWC's assets and its refusal to distribute significant cash and marketable securities to the shareholders. We intend to send this message to the Board and management by withholding our votes for CSWC's slate of directors at this year's annual meeting if there are no tangible actions taken by that time. We believe withholding our votes will send a message that independent shareholders are not satisfied with the status quo, and that we demand the Board and management work to ensure that shareholder value is maximized. We hope all shareholders will call, email or write to CSWC to voice support for the approximate $82 per share distribution and that the Board and management will take the necessary actions to maximize shareholder value." The full text of the letter follows: ZS Crossover II L.P. Ned L. Sherwood (212) 398-6200 May 29, 2008 Mr. Gary Martin and Dear Mr. Martin and the Board of Directors: We are disappointed that the Capital Southwest Corporation ("CSWC", or "the Company") Board of Directors ("the Board") and management team chose to fight to exclude our non-binding proposal from the Company's proxy statement. We were surprised that a company that ostensibly prides itself on supporting shareholder rights would continually attempt to silence the voice of its largest independent shareholder. However, given CSWC's poor investment record over the past 10 years and what appears to be its more than 40-year record of inaccurately recording its net asset value, we can understand why the Company would spend shareholder dollars in an attempt to avoid a shareholder vote on a non-binding proposal. Your efforts to block our shareholder proposal only serve to reinforce our belief that you are keenly aware that many other independent shareholders share our views. We remind the members of the Board that the shareholders are the true owners of the Company, and that the Board has a fiduciary duty to act in their best interests. As CSWC's largest independent shareholder, our interests are aligned with all shareholders. Thanks largely to our efforts, the Company has recently taken the following steps benefiting all shareholders that have resulted in the correction of previously incorrect accounting treatments, a material increase in reported net asset value, and the elimination of obfuscations of net asset value: -- On November 20, 2007, CSWC announced that it would restate past SEC -- As of March 31, 2008, CSWC reported that it had obtained some form of -- As of March 31, 2008, CSWC also reduced the valuation discounts on its
The fact is the market currently values the Company's assets at 68 cents on the dollar. We believe that this discount is directly attributable to the poor investment performance of CSWC over the past 10 years. We have asked CSWC management why it insists on retaining the large blocks of the four major public companies rather than registering and distributing them, as these securities would likely be valued much closer to dollar-for-dollar in the open market if distributed. Management has responded with feeble answers, saying that they, rather than individual shareholders, are better stewards of these major holdings. We note, however, that since March 31, 1998 the return CSWC has achieved on its public holdings has been a cumulative loss of 54.3%, or a compound annual rate of return of negative 7.4%. Although HLYS has been a large component of this loss since its IPO, even excluding HLYS entirely would imply a cumulative loss of 28.4%, or a compound annual rate of return of negative 3.2%. Based on these results, we seriously doubt that the Company is a better steward of this capital than its shareholders would be. As evidenced by the discount at which the stock trades relative to net asset value, the market seems to agree with us. We believe that to prevent further erosion of shareholder value, CSWC should register and distribute the shares of these four public holdings before year-end on a pro-rata basis to shareholders. In addition to protecting shareholder value, such a distribution would result in shareholders being able to take advantage of the current federal capital gains tax rate of 15% and not be at risk for the increase in this tax rate to 20% or greater that may be instituted with a new administration in the White House next year. We believe the time for decisive action by the Board and management is long overdue and that other significant independent shareholders agree with us. Furthermore, as stewards of a Business Development Company, it is the Board's and management's responsibility to accurately present CSWC's net asset value on a quarterly and annual basis in order to maximize shareholder value. We wonder why management and the Board did not take steps to more accurately account for the true market value of the Company's holdings until we publicly called for the changing of certain policies. Moreover, management and the Board must move more swiftly to enact the further changes necessary to maximize shareholder value. Until the Board and management can assure shareholders that the Company's assets are accurately accounted for, shareholders of CSWC will have ample reason to be displeased with the conduct of the Board and management. We plan to closely monitor CSWC's actions over the coming weeks for evidence that the Company is taking tangible steps to address our serious concerns. We suggest the following: 1. The sale of CSWC's approximately $54 million of unrestricted public 2. The registration and distribution of the four major public holdings to
Clearly, we are displeased with the Board's cavalier attitude towards valuation of the Company's assets and its refusal to distribute significant cash and marketable securities to the shareholders. We intend to send this message to the Board and management by withholding our votes for CSWC's slate of directors at this year's annual meeting if there are no tangible actions taken by that time. We believe withholding our votes will send a message that independent shareholders are not satisfied with the status quo, and that we demand the Board and management work to ensure that shareholder value is maximized. Investing "patient capital" does not equate to operating the Company with lax and inattentive Board supervision and management. After more than ten years of poor investment performance and minimal distributions to shareholders, we believe the current Board and management no longer deserve the benefit of the doubt. We hope all shareholders will call, email or write to the Company to voice support for the approximate $82 per share distribution and that the Board and management will take the necessary actions to maximize shareholder value. Sincerely, Ned Sherwood
CONTACT: Ned Sherwood for ZS Crossover II L.P., +1-212-398-6200
2008-05-29 18:49:15 0373420 PRNEWSWIRE
HOME || Press Release Archive || © Leigh Media Corporation || Terms of Use || Privacy Policy || Publish Your Press Release Here |